Call This Mystery Solved

By Kat La Mantia | August 27 2025 | AdultsAllBlogGeneralPop Culture

Mysteries aren’t just for the bookstores! With Richard Osman’s hit bestseller The Thursday Murder Club now coming to Netflix, the mystery genre is officially back in the pop culture zeitgeist.

As folks seek out escapism during turbulent times, murder mysteries and whodunnits that deliver light-hearted thrills with page-turning suspense are just what the doctor ordered. And with new interactive formats (think Murdle or Hunt a Killer), fans can become the detective themselves for a uniquely immersive mystery experience!

Fall is the perfect time to dive into this genre, providing a cozier, playful contrast to horror and true crime books that dominate the season. Lean into immersion and escapism with You Are the Detective: The Creeping Hand Murder, where YOU are tasked with combing through evidence and deciphering clues to solve a scandalous murder in 1930s London. Revisit the classics with Agatha Christie’s literary legends Miss Marple and Hercule Poirot as they solve cases in quaint English villages, or draw on some retro childhood nostalgia with books from Choose Your Own Adventure’s original run, now back in print after 25 years!

Building a cozy season display? Don’t forget to include some cozy mysteries like the seasonal suspense story Pumpkin Spice Peril, Sofie Ryan’s beloved feline detective Second Chance Cat Mystery series, or Laura Childs’s A Tea Shop Mystery series (which is screaming to be paired with boutique tea blends and adorable mugs).

See some of our favorite mystery books and gifts down below, then click into our title list to shop the full collection!

More Mystery Must-Haves
All Mystery Fiction

A Novel
9780593513033
A New York Times Bestseller | Now a Netflix Film “Think of the Thursday Murder Club itself as a senior version of ‘The A-Team.’...Funny, moving, and suspenseful...So delicious, even adorable.”—The Washington Post Four septuagenarians with a few tricks up their sleeves. A female cop with her first big case. A brutal murder. Welcome to...THE THURSDAY MURDER CLUB
$18.00 US
Aug 12, 2025
5-1/2 x 8-1/4
Paperback
384 Pages
Penguin Books

9798217333387
Thursday Murder Club: Official Member Enamel Pin
$10.50 US
Sep 23, 2025
Merchandise
Out of Print

9780593836019
November 1933. London. Seven people receive mysterious letters. Someone knows their terrible secrets. They are summoned to a posh townhouse where one is stabbed right in front of the others, but somehow no one saw a thing. Can you help Scotland Yard solve the mystery? An interactive murder mystery from the bestselling author and illustrator of Your Guide to Not Getting Murdered in a Quaint English Village
$19.99 US
Sep 16, 2025
7 x 9
Hardcover
128 Pages
Ten Speed Press

A gorgeous gift edition of the world’s greatest crime writer’s best and most influential mystery
9781782279174
A beautifully produced edition of the world’s greatest crime writer’s best and most influential mystery, which changed the game with an unprecedented plot twist
$22.00 US
Oct 25, 2022
5-1/16 x 7-13/16
Hardcover
320 Pages
Pushkin Vertigo

9781937133054
Finally back in print after a 25-year wait! Unlock the mystery of Chimney Rock in this iconic interactive book where YOU decide what happens next! Packed with 36 possible endings! Choose Your Own Adventure books–the 4th bestselling children’s series of all time–are back and as much fun as you remember. Kids and adults agree, these are the books that get 9- to 12-year-olds reading.
$8.99 US
Nov 04, 2025
4-3/16 x 6-7/8
Paperback
144 Pages
Choose Your Own Adventure
Age 9-12 years

A Golden Girls Cozy Mystery
9781368102988
***Instant NEW YORK TIMES bestseller*** The first novel in the all-new Golden Girls Cozy Mystery Series! When Dorothy’s obnoxious date is found dead in a hotel freezer, it not only ruins a gorgeous cheesecake but threatens the elaborate St. Olaf–themed wedding Rose is hosting.
$16.99 US
Apr 15, 2025
5-1/2 x 8-1/4
Paperback
336 Pages
Hyperion Avenue

A Set of Holmes-Inspired Card Games
9780593797327
The game is afoot! With this six-in-one set of 60 cards plus rules book, two to six players can become the detectives as they unravel the iconic mysteries of Sherlock Holmes.
$20.00 US
Aug 12, 2025
3-15/16 x 5-3/8
Game
60 Pages
Clarkson Potter

9780141192437
Part of Penguin's beautiful hardback Clothbound Classics series, designed by the award-winning Coralie Bickford-Smith, these delectable and collectible editions are bound in high-quality colourful, tactile cloth with foil stamped into the design. The terrible spectacle of the beast, the fog of the moor, the discovery of a body, this classic horror story pits detective against dog. When Sir Charles Baskerville is found dead on the wild Devon moorland with the footprints of a giant hound nearby, the blame is placed on a family curse. It is left to Sherlock Holmes and Doctor Watson to solve the mystery of the legend of the phantom hound before Sir Charles' heir comes to an equally gruesome end.
$21.00 US
Sep 28, 2010
5-1/16 x 7-3/4
Hardcover
240 Pages
Penguin Classics

More than 100 Recipes from Today's Bestselling Mystery Authors
9780425277867
MORE THAN 100 RECIPES FROMAVERY AAMES/DARYL WOOD GERBERELLERY ADAMSCONNIE ARCHERLESLIE BUDEWITZLAURA CHILDSCLEO COYLEVICTORIA HAMILTONB. B. HAYWOODJULIE HYZYJENN McKINLAYPAIGE SHELTONGreat meals don’t have to be a mystery—but they can come from a mystery. Selecting the most delicious recipes from some of the most popular names in crime solving, The Cozy Cookbook serves up mouth-watering appetizers, entrèes, and desserts that will leave your family or book club group asking, “Whodunit?”In addition to recipes, choose a sleuth du jour from our menu of mystery series and get a taste of each of our authors’ bread and butter—page-turning puzzles and stay-up-all-night suspense in excerpts from their bestselling works.Whether you like your meals sautéed, roasted, baked, or served cold like revenge, The Cozy Cookbook has something to satisfy every mystery fan.This book contains previously published material.
$17.00 US
Apr 07, 2015
6 x 8-1/4
Paperback
384 Pages
Berkley

9780451492654
In the twelfth Cupcake Bakery Mystery from New York Times bestselling author Jenn McKinlay, the Fairy Tale Cupcake crew follows the clever crumb trail of a killer who's anything but cookie-cutter.
$9.99 US
Apr 28, 2020
4-3/16 x 6-3/4
Mass Market Paperback
272 Pages
Berkley

9798217116775
Don't miss the special edition of the the global phenomenon, featuring sprayed edges and exclusive content from mutimillion copy bestselling author Holly Jackson!
$14.99 US
Jun 10, 2025
5-1/2 x 8-1/4
Paperback
416 Pages
Delacorte Press
Age 14 and up

9781984859624
Thinking of a foray to a quaint English village? You'll think twice after reading this tongue-in-cheek illustrated guide to the countless murderous possibilities lurking behind these villages' bucolic façades--from bestselling author Maureen Johnson and illustrator Jay Cooper.
$16.99 US
Sep 14, 2021
5-1/2 x 7-1/2
Hardcover
128 Pages
Ten Speed Press